Florida’s Forgotten Islands: Hidden Gems Off the Beaten Path
Florida is famous for its theme parks, bustling beaches, and lively cities, but hidden along its vast coastline are islands that remain untouched by mass tourism. These lesser-known destinations offer solitude, adventure, and a glimpse into Florida’s natural beauty and history. Here’s a journey through some of the Sunshine State’s most overlooked islands—places where time slows, nature thrives, and history lingers.
Keewaydin Island: A Boat-Only Paradise
Tucked between Naples and Marco Island, Keewaydin Island is an undeveloped barrier island that can only be reached by boat. Unlike its more famous neighbors, Keewaydin has no roads, no bridges, and no high-rises—just pure, untouched beach.
Why Visit?
Seclusion: Even on busy weekends, you can find a quiet stretch of sand.
Wildlife: Home to nesting sea turtles, shorebirds, and dolphins.
Beach Camping: For the adventurous, Keewaydin allows primitive camping, offering a chance to sleep under the stars with the sound of waves in the background.
How to Get There:
Take a private boat or use the Keewaydin Island Shuttle.
Rent a boat from Naples Boat Rentals.
Cayo Costa: Florida’s Wildest Island
If you want a taste of what Florida looked like before development, Cayo Costa State Park is the place to go. Located off the Gulf Coast near Fort Myers, this island is only accessible by boat or ferry.
Highlights:
Nine Miles of Pristine Beaches: No condos, no crowds—just you, the dunes, and the waves.
Historic Remnants: Once home to Native American tribes and early settlers, the island still holds traces of its past.
Kayaking and Snorkeling: Explore the mangroves and seagrass beds filled with manatees and tropical fish.
How to Visit:
Take the Cayo Costa Ferry from Pine Island.
Rent a kayak and paddle over from Bokeelia.
Seahorse Key: A Mysterious Island with a Dark Past
Part of the Cedar Keys National Wildlife Refuge, Seahorse Key is one of Florida’s most intriguing islands. Once a military outpost and later a quarantine station for yellow fever patients, this small island carries a ghostly air of history.
Why It’s Special:
Historic Lighthouse: Built in 1854, the lighthouse still stands but is only open to visitors a few days a year.
Wildlife Refuge: The island serves as a breeding ground for thousands of seabirds.
Haunting Past: Local legends speak of eerie noises and mysterious lights seen from the shore.
How to Explore:
Seahorse Key is only open to visitors on select dates. Check the Cedar Keys National Wildlife Refuge website for details.
Book a guided tour with Cedar Key Boat Rentals.
Dry Tortugas: The Most Remote Island Adventure
Located 70 miles west of Key West, Dry Tortugas National Park is one of the most remote and breathtaking destinations in Florida. The island is home to Fort Jefferson, a massive 19th-century fortress, and some of the best snorkeling in the state.
Things to Do:
Snorkel the Coral Reefs: Swim among shipwrecks, tropical fish, and vibrant coral.
Tour Fort Jefferson: Learn about the island’s Civil War history and its role as a prison.
Camp Under the Stars: The lack of light pollution makes this one of the best stargazing spots in Florida.
Getting There:
Take the Yankee Freedom Ferry from Key West.
Fly via Key West Seaplane Adventures for a breathtaking aerial view.
Final Thoughts
Florida’s forgotten islands offer a different kind of magic—one free from crowds, traffic, and high-rise hotels. Whether you seek solitude, adventure, or a touch of history, these hidden gems provide a chance to experience the Sunshine State in its rawest and most beautiful form.
So next time you're planning a Florida getaway, consider skipping the theme parks and heading off the beaten path—you might just find your own private paradise.
Would you like more details on any of these islands or help planning a trip?